“The Lady Eve” (1941): The Screwball Comedy That Trips You Up

Some comedies make you laugh at their characters. The Lady Eve makes you laugh with one of them — a card sharp who is better at her job than anyone around her, and who falls in love in the middle of a con.

Henry Fonda and Barbara Stanwyck

Preston Sturges wrote and directed The Lady Eve for Paramount in 1941, adapting a story by Monckton Hoffe that earned an Academy Award nomination for Best Original Story. Barbara Stanwyck plays Jean Harrington, who works on an ocean liner with her father, “Colonel” Harrington (Charles Coburn), fleecing wealthy passengers at cards. Their new target is Charles Pike (Henry Fonda), the shy heir to a brewing fortune, who has spent a year up the Amazon studying snakes and wants nothing more than a quiet voyage home.

Jean’s method is simple: she trips him. Literally, from that first pratfall — one of many Fonda takes with wonderful dignity — the film becomes a duel between Jean’s professional polish and Charles’s complete innocence. Stanwyck is in total command, watching Charles in her compact mirror while narrating his romantic prospects to herself, then softening, against every rule of her trade, because the mark turns out to be genuinely kind.

Then comes the turn that lifts The Lady Eve above ordinary screwball. Charles learns the truth, and Jean—stung at being judged—takes revenge by reappearing in his life disguised as Lady Eve Sidwich, a supposed English aristocrat. The disguise fools nobody watching the film, which is precisely the joke, and somehow fools Charles completely, which is the greater one. Sturges is saying something sly here: we fall in love with the person, then invent the story that lets us do it.

The supporting cast is a small orchestra of comic types. William Demarest grumbles and growls as Charles’s bodyguard Muggsy, the only man aboard who suspects everyone and is right about almost everything. Eugene Pallette, as Charles’s father, delivers every line as if announcing it to a crowded room. Eric Blore and Melville Cooper fuss beautifully around the edges. Nobody wastes a scene.

What keeps the film fresh, more than eighty years on, is its balance of heart and mischief. Jean is never punished into respectability, and Charles is never made cleverer than he is; the film simply lets two mismatched people circle back to each other, older and slightly bruised. The Lady Eve was added to the National Film Registry in 1994 and still appears on lists of the greatest comedies ever made — the American Film Institute included it among its hundred funniest American films. If you have never seen Stanwyck trip a millionaire, you are one viewing away from a perfect evening.

About the author: The StreamHubOnline Team writes classic-film reviews, ending explainers, and viewing guides at StreamHubOnline — https://streamhubonline.com/. We don’t host or stream films; we just love writing about them.

 

Would you like to write a guest blog? Check out how it works by clicking on the Guest Blogs tab above.